179 Comments
User's avatar
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

I run a community not-quite-book-substack called The Books That Made Us.

Every post is written by a different guest writer on a foundational book. A book they feel made them who they are today.

More details here:

https://booksthatmadeus.substack.com

Expand full comment
Emily Rhodes's avatar

This looks wonderful!

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

Thanks, Emily. Would absolutely love to feature a post from yourself at some point, if you can spare the time!

Also, am sad I hadn’t discovered your book club when I was still living in London, would have loved to join the walks!

Expand full comment
Emily Rhodes's avatar

Ah wow, I'd love to, thanks! And hopefully you'll be passing through London at some point in the future ....

Let's be in touch!

Expand full comment
TaraShea Nesbit's avatar

Love that you got featured here, Emily!

Expand full comment
Victoria K. Walker's avatar

Such an inspired idea for a Substack ✨💫

Expand full comment
Tatiana's avatar

Can’t wait to read it!

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

Supposed to read ‘not-quite-a-book-club Substack’🤦🏼‍♂️

Expand full comment
Olivia Barry's avatar

I love this. 👏👏

Expand full comment
SJStone's avatar

Love this idea! I have a shelf full of my favorite books. I don't think I've ever thought to write about why those books are on that shelf. Seems like a worthy project.

Expand full comment
Noah Sochaczevski's avatar

This is awesome! I just read some old posts and subscribed. Would love to write something like this - I already know the PERFECT book haha

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

Please send in a pitch!

Expand full comment
Susan Wittig Albert's avatar

This is what I love about Substack! Everybody's great ideas, all together in one place. I'm in learning mode and this is just what I was looking for. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Rebecca EH's avatar

Agreed! A book club would integrate beautifully with my newsletter, but it hadn't occurred to me until I saw this post.

Expand full comment
Kalpana Mohan's avatar

I don’t run a club BUT I write about books in translation from around the world. I think what I find weekly has to be shared with my fellow humans who love to know about other cultures and other times. More at http://kalpanamohan.substack.com Last week it was a German book from the time of Hitler. The week prior was a collection of Tamil stories. Prior to that was a Spanish Xavier Marias work. Assamese. Catalonian. Telugu. Vietnamese. Marathi. I’m having fun.

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Wow! Kalpana - I am amazed by the range of your reading, the depth of your discussion (including author biographies, information about translators, some national/cultural history when needed), and the wit of your prose. AND then come your beautiful travel photos, when relevant. Good grief! I also write about books, so I know how much you provide to your readers on a weekly basis.

***All book fans: Be sure to check out Kalpana's Letters from Everywhere! ***

Here is a recent sample with biography, history, and description of a book :

https://kalpanamohan.substack.com/p/a-german-war-classic-from-singapore

Subscribed.

Expand full comment
Kalpana Mohan's avatar

Thank you so much, Tara!!!! I appreciate your words so much. Yes, it has been a lot of work and I’m doing it for the love, while building the first draft of my third book. I do hope I’ll be able to sustain it. 😬

Expand full comment
Lata Kokal's avatar

Wow. What is your 3rd book going to be about, Kalpana?

Expand full comment
Rebecca EH's avatar

Love this concept, just subscribed! I write a newsletter highlighting works by creators from across the Asian diaspora -- let me know if you'd be interested in collaborating :)

Expand full comment
Kalpana Mohan's avatar

Sure, sounds wonderful. When I finish my work day I’ll go and read what you’re doing!

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Kalpana - If you read anything that strikes you as wondrous and enchanting, would you Restack it in a Note and tag me @ Tara Penry? I keep a monthly digest of enchanting Substack reads. You are casting a wide net and bound to see some. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Masoud's avatar

Like

Expand full comment
Kalpana Mohan's avatar

Sure I will!!!!

Expand full comment
Kalpana Mohan's avatar

I tagged you on two posts about books I found very moving.

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Reading them . . . thank you!

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Yay! Thank you! 😄

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Wow 🤩

Expand full comment
Hurley Winkler's avatar

When I rolled out paid subscriptions last year, a book club felt like the perfect thing to offer! My Book Club for Writers discusses books about the craft of writing. We're having our third meeting on July 30. It's been a blast!

Expand full comment
Masoud's avatar

Like

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

That's awesome! Feel free to leave your own tips on running a book club for other writers here.

Expand full comment
Masoud's avatar

Like

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

🙌🙌🙌

Expand full comment
Victoria K. Walker's avatar

This is wonderful, thank you for highlighting these Substacks - I look forward to reading more about them. I keep toying with the idea of launching a monthly discussion thread a la the salons of the Bloomsbury Group writers and artists - to discuss the previous month’s biographies. Much to think about. Thank you again!

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

I would definitely enjoy that, Victoria

Expand full comment
Victoria K. Walker's avatar

Thank you. Maybe I need to stop just thinking...

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Yeah!!

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

Love the salon idea Victoria!

Expand full comment
Victoria K. Walker's avatar

Thank you Hannah :)

Expand full comment
Lara Chapman's avatar

I’m more of a dystopian novel reader, but I suppose I can check out the utopian novel list from Griffin. ☺️

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Fictionistas, the Lunar Awards, and Erica Drayton’s “The List” are two places to find more fiction writers. Someone is surely writing dystopias. :-)

Expand full comment
J. M. Elliott's avatar

Don’t forget about The Library! https://thelinklibrary.substack.com

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Right!

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Oops - three places!

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

As a fellow dystopian lover, I’d say the two are inextricably inter-twined ;) Elle's reading list is well worth checking out. (Current read: Brave New World. You?)

Expand full comment
Lara Chapman's avatar

The last one I read was Margaret Atwood “the heart goes last “ Pretty interesting read! Unfortunately, I’m not reading anything dystopian currently although I did just start reading “their eyes were watching god” definitely not a dystopian novel. But interesting book and I had never read it before. 😀

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Ditto. Favourite dystopian novel?

Expand full comment
Lara Chapman's avatar

This is a great one: “We” by Russian writer Yevgeny Zamyatin

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Good shout. I only read that recently actually, but it was impressive.

Expand full comment
Lara Chapman's avatar

There was also another one I read a few years ago, that I really enjoyed I forget the authors name, but he’s Japanese, and it was about young people being cloned, and their body parts used for wealthy humans. It was really well done.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go?

Expand full comment
Lara Chapman's avatar

If you have any suggestions for any titles, and I will see if I’ve read them yet if not, I will buy them and add it to my library

Expand full comment
artemis dreaming's avatar

Thank you for this! I’ve long thought about both joining and running a book club. Lots of great ideas here.

Expand full comment
Kevin McSpadden's avatar

This is pretty cool, and a unique idea. I hadn't even considered this as a possible "substack world" but I'm glad I know about it. Fun stuff.

Expand full comment
Jocelyn Flores's avatar

I’ve started my substack page in hopes to start a cookbook club! I try recipes from a different cookbook each month. I hope to one day have group discussions with my readers as they cook along with me.

Expand full comment
Rebecca EH's avatar

Such a good idea!! Cookbooks are my latest obsession.

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

This sounds rad!

Expand full comment
artemis dreaming's avatar

Love this idea!

Expand full comment
Rachael Shah's avatar

Wonderful ideas 💡

Expand full comment
Stacy Igel's avatar

This is amazing this is why I love you Substack!

Expand full comment
Timothy Atkinson's avatar

I plan on starting one of these down the road with a focus on subversive fiction.

Expand full comment
Laura Kennedy's avatar

Thanks for including the Peak Notions book club! I’m figuring it out along with subscribers every month, but most liked the idea of a book club that doesn’t commit you to ever book or session. People sign up only when they’re interested in the book, and my hope is that this ensures a small group of enthusiastic attendees and a good conversation every time!

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

I love how flexible that idea is, and how it allows a more permeable attendee group, while keeps the engagement and conversation quality high.

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

👍👍

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

I love this thread!

I run a Zoom book club that reads classic works of literature by dead authors -- Dickens, Baldwin, Woolf, Vonnegut, Didion -- and I also read biographies of those writers so that during book club meetings I can tell stories about their lives and how they created their masterpieces. People all over the world, ages 18-80, participate, including lots of writers, musicians, filmmakers, etc., plus normal folks too.

We record the Zoom meetings, and then I drag those recordings into iMovie, edit them down to the funniest and most insightful comments, and post those videos to Substack for my paid subscribers.

I also run something called the Silent Reading Party (which I invented in 2009) where a live musician plays piano for two hours in the lobby of a 100-year-old hotel in Seattle (Hotel Sorrento). Music designed to be read to. For people to tune out digital distractions and get some reading done with a community of others who are doing the same thing.

During the pandemic, we started a virtual version of the reading party -- a live broadcast on Zoom of the live music. Paid subscribers to my substack get those reading party Zoom links free every first and third Wednesday of the month. Unlike the book clubs, there is no talking at the reading party.

More info on the reading party: silentreadingparty.com

Upcoming book clubs: FrizzLit.com/bookclubs

Deals and discounts on all of the above available for my free subscribers here ✨

Expand full comment
Yasmin Chopin's avatar

Your ideas are really interesting. How long does it take to edit those Zoom recordings?

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Quite a long time. Several days.

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Sounds pretty cool. Long love reading!

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Hear, hear!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 18, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Sri Juneja's avatar

Thanks for including Readable Moments Book Club in this amazing list! ❤️

Expand full comment
Cassie Gutman's avatar

I have a book recommendation newsletter! I focus on non-bestsellers that may have flown under the radar for people looking to branch out of the popular reads they have already read!

https://readingundertheradar.substack.com

Expand full comment
Emily Rhodes's avatar

I love your newsletter!

Expand full comment
Cassie Gutman's avatar

Eee thank you so much!

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Love this 🙏

Expand full comment
Noah Sochaczevski's avatar

This is awesome! Just read through and subscribed.

Expand full comment
Brooklyn Lindsey's avatar

A substack world I'd happily get lost in. Thank you for the list, it's beautifully curated, each book club uniquely described. This whole situation is what I'm here for. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Woot woot

Expand full comment