177 Comments

I don’t think you understand how different my audience and my interests are from my contact list.

I want to grow my network, not connect with my aunt Judie and the local pizza place.

Expand full comment

Giving your Contacts info seems like the very Orwellian situation most Substack writers have come here to avoid.

Expand full comment
Aug 14, 2023·edited Aug 15, 2023

There we go, comments working and third post hits the spot 😆

Good info in this one. Helps explain it much more clearly. I like the stepping-stone flirtation of the Follow before the Subscribe.

Question: do you get notified if someone follows you?

edit: regarding contact lists from phone. Didn't see this before and I agree, I don't want to share my own contact list. Happy to have the follow feature and be able to follow, but sharing a list of contacts without my contacts having consent seems a bit...off.

Expand full comment

I like Substack because I don't have contact with people I know.

Expand full comment

This is a great feature! Question: Can you consider stop hosting/promoting white supremacists on your official podcast?

Expand full comment

Is there a way to toggle this off?

Expand full comment

Substack gets worse every month. You claim you don't want to be like social media, and then implement feature after feature that does just that. This latest is another step in the wrong direction, another attempt to make the platform more like Twitter or Facebook or whatever. You have an awesome core mission, but aren't satisfied with sticking to it and making the core even better.

All these tacky add-ons just dilute what Substack used to be about.

And in this thread, I just learned that people's subscriber list is available to the public. What a rotten disappointment. One of the better things about Substack was that your connections (ie. subscribers) was private. With every move you make, it's more of the social status, competitive, look at my numbers! crap that drove me from Twitter. Big fail.

Expand full comment

Another misguided step by Substack. Trying to be a Twitter or FB instead of trying to be Substack and improve core features.

Expand full comment

Does this actually make it “easier to grow our subscriber base,” or does it just help you build a Twitter replacement, because ex-Twitter users don’t expect to get emails from everyone they follow? Won’t this reduce subscriber growth for authors who don’t use notes?

Expand full comment

I have but one friend and I already know where he lives.

Expand full comment

Kind of a bummer. What I love about substack is that it feels like a private little internet corner away from social media, and it feels like it’s becoming more and more social media-like

Expand full comment

I'm not sure I'm ... following you ... LOL ...

Expand full comment

Never, ever, under any circumstances would I give Substack or any platform access to my personal contacts. It feels slimy. And I would never want someone to do that with my info without my permission. Besides, my mechanic and my gas company don't care a flip about my writing.

Expand full comment

Q: Will there be a setting that allows writers to lock posts to followers? If followers by default have access to everything free subscribers do, this would not help writers build audiences. It would just fully convert the writer to an aspect of Substack’s UX for readers

Expand full comment

I'm curious, is anyone concerned that with so much more focus on Notes that there's a lot less reading or engagement on posts? I'm starting to wonder if there's a decrease or not as people spend more time on Notes and less time reading long-form posts.

Expand full comment

Looks like people I muted now showing up if someone I follow likes or restacks their post. Would be great to keep the mutes out of the Notes timeline.

Expand full comment