94 Comments
User's avatar
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

Thank you for reading everyone!! 🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶 stick to your newsletter long enough to see it flourish, don't give up.

Expand full comment
Dahlia Rimmon's avatar

I love your optimism!

Expand full comment
Kuba Grzeda's avatar

Thanks for coming to the comments! I really enjoyed your perspective on Instagram and the fact that your newsletter is and will likely be (at least for a while) free.

I was wondering if you'd be able to share eany tips for inviting guests and guest posts? I would like to explore that as well, but don't want to put anyone off by asking... thanks very much!

Expand full comment
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

At first you'll get a lot of "No"s but eventually you'll be graced by luck and get a "Yes" and then another... and then another.. and then another... and so on. It'll always be hard and you'll have to get creative with your pitch/strategy.

Expand full comment
Lisa Brunette's avatar

Great advice! Thanks for taking the time to share, with candor.

Expand full comment
Kuba Grzeda's avatar

Thank you! Time to shoot out some emails 🌟

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

Starts out slow but believe in your writing ✍️

Expand full comment
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

Good luck!

Expand full comment
Elfin Waters's avatar

Such a wonderful message! I'm just starting out so I loved this injection of optimism. And I love how you're focused on talking about quality stuff and not "selling out" just yet. Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Lisa Brunette's avatar

Great question!

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

🙌❤️👌

Expand full comment
Dahlia Rimmon's avatar

This was a great and positive article about growth. Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

👌👌❤️

Expand full comment
Ivan H's avatar

Wow what a great inspiring story! Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Kuba Grzeda's avatar

Dang, this is inspiring! Thank you for sharing.

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

Wow good for these guys! I can't imaging posting that often and also throwing all those parties on top of working a full-time gig. Curious why they haven't at least launched a paid option for folks who want to support them even if they decide to keep all the content free.

I love that I also live in and mainly write about people in NYC, but I have never heard of any of the big NYC "names" they've featured in their own NYC-based Substack. It just shows me that even within one location, there's so much room on this platform for exploring different aspects of life and appealing to completely different readerships

Expand full comment
James Kung's avatar

Never been prouder of my favorite boys online ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Expand full comment
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

Day 1 🫶

Expand full comment
Martin Prior's avatar

Wow, growing from 0 to 30,000 in three years is amazing.

Certainly inspiring to think that they’ve done it while holding down two jobs.

Strange that they’ve not monetised at all. They could turn on paid and ask for donations while keeping it free. They’d only need a small percentage of conversions to make it work.

Expand full comment
John Neill's avatar

I am 89 and have not given up. I have written three works of fiction under my pen name, Pat Muir, that have not sold. I have written ten movie scripts that have gone nowhere- see Coverfly. I am now writing a blog about what ex-slaves said to interviewers in 1936-38. See slavewords.substrack

Expand full comment
Hunter Burgtorf's avatar

I loved reading this! It's so inspiring to see how they've committed to it and stuck to consistent content and have seen awesome results.

Expand full comment
Taegan MacLean's avatar

Honestly, it’s so, so cool to see how the Perfectly Imperfect peeps respond to comments in the thread. I’m definitely taking a page out of your book. Thanks for doing what you do!

Expand full comment
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

👌👌

Expand full comment
Brian Reindel 👾⚔️'s avatar

As a fellow software engineer, I'm curious about your approach for the recommendations you've built. Substack doesn't have an API, but you are pulling from the CDN directly and possibly crawling your own Substack in real time. Any roadblocks you can share? I've considered a similar approach, but I am wary of violating the TOS.

Expand full comment
Annie Nicole's avatar

Hi, I'm curious that your page is always at the top of my list, and I wonder if there is some kind of connection ..Hope my comment didn't bother you. I wish you a happy life.

Expand full comment
Claudia Befu's avatar

What have you done?

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

👌👌

Expand full comment
Scoot's avatar

Was posting a perfectly imperfect (P.I.) feature on Pi day on purpose?

This was a great article and contained a lot of useful nuggets, but none more useful than "don't give up!" Thank you!

Expand full comment
Hannah Ray's avatar

No but very fitting indeed!

Expand full comment
George G's avatar

Pleased to say that my Substack’s balance of growth against remaining cool is very even right now.

Expand full comment
Perfectly Imperfect's avatar

A difficult balance!

Expand full comment
Brad Thomas Parsons's avatar

Always love when a new PI drops!

Expand full comment
Potoa'e Kelemete's avatar

@Perfectly imperfect, thanks for sharing the Gold dust ✨️ of encouragement, inspiring to keep driving. I needed it👍

Expand full comment
CHINC's avatar

hey kelemete i like your comment and kelemete help me to continue my studies thanks for your help

Expand full comment
Potoa'e Kelemete's avatar

@Chinc, you got this ✍️💯

Expand full comment
CHINC's avatar

thank you very much if you will tell me how you will help me because now my home is in Rwanda but I have found a way to continue my studies in another country it would help me so if you will help me kelement🙏🙏

Expand full comment
Kathy's avatar

Dear sirs.

I must say which everyone of you spoke through this Substacks, you write the same way I do, I'm sure there is a word for it. You were a inviting read. spoke to me like a real person ( which I am for sure). I would like to subscribe to your Substacks, but I'm having trouble with my Substacks, It has no phone number to call, that I can find.

Just wanted you, to know that you are brilliant the way you talk to your readers. It's exactly what I want to do. and talk I love to talk and have an amazing story to tell and I to would fell bad about asking your devoted readers for money, how ever you do take care of business and sounds like you could come up with something, to get paid help you with gas at least, I thought maybe I would in my situation share more details of my world, I'm writing about my mom and me and the missing on a milk carton life I thought I could take the more juice stores behind the paywall.

Thanks again for the read.

K. Williams

of "Uncharted Truths"

Expand full comment
Michael Mohr's avatar

👌👌👌❤️

Expand full comment