Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Roland (CA->WA)'s avatar

GIVING A DONATION TO AN AUTHOR (other than the exceedingly restrictive subscription choices)

Substack does not have a means of giving a donation of $10, $20, $50 or whatever to an author. I’ve communicated with Substack and they don’t seem to think that’s a priority. You can’t send a donation to an author. It’s lifetime subscription (only one numerical figure available), monthly subscription (only one numerical figure available), or nothing. This is a for-profit business, at least I thought so. They would get a percentage of that if it went through them. But noooooo, that’s not an option they think merits their time or attention. Substack and one of my authors (I subscribe to 3) have already lost out because a month ago I was moved to send a largish donation but was unable to do so because I am already at lifetime subscriber level with this person, and I was unable to send an additional donation. The moment has passed, but it left me with a cranky feeling.

Isn’t there a way to provide at least a little more versatility, so that if a subscriber is moved to do so, they can send money? I have the authors email address and we converse by email, but I haven’t raised the possibility of him giving me his financial info so I can send him money.

Subject has a system of sending money from reader to Substack author, but I find the choices so restrictive as to be stifling.

Any chance of adding real versatility?

Roland

Expand full comment
Lisa Jensen's avatar

I echo this! I really wish Substack had this option. I write a newletter for Covid long-haulers, many of whom are in dire financial straits. I don't want to prevent people from accessing content because they can't afford to pay for a subscription, so after several months with the subscription model, I made it free to everyone. (I found that just telling people they could email me and I would give them a free subscription wasn't enough. Many people don't feel comfortable doing that.) I created a 'buy me a coffee' page, and though I still do all my writing through Substack, I add a 'buy me a coffee' button to the bottom of my newsletters. I've been surprised by the generosity of readers, and I love that everyone can access it, whether or not they can help me get a caffeine fix. I wish that the donation option was built seamlessly into Substack, though. It would be easier for me, simpler for my readers, and financially more beneficial for Substack.

Expand full comment
Elle Griffin's avatar

I agree. I need more pricing tiers, and if I can’t get them I’ll have to create an off-platform way to gather that extra revenue.

Expand full comment
Roland (CA->WA)'s avatar

“SUBSTACK has a system of sending money from reader to author . . . “

Expand full comment
Rob Shouting Into The Void's avatar

Well it's working, I know spend more per month than I soent per year on my old magazine subscriptions. My only real complaint is there are just too many damm good writers 😁 and to be honest it is a nice problem to have!

Expand full comment
3musesmerge's avatar

From my first introduction, I was attracted to the “why” behind Substack’s model. When you give people an opportunity to create, grow and share — amazing things happen. Congrats Substack/founders. I am delighted to be one of your writers.

Expand full comment
Corrado's avatar

Guys, don't leave the non USA writers alone. I write my newsletter in Italian language and it is impossible to get paid for a newetter. You should have national references (I candidate myself for Italy) to help all the writers and you to be really a world platform

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

A lot of us have blogged on other platforms. Blogger has become a messy place plus all the sales pitches and odd things that appear in comments. Word Press became very complex and not handy. You provide a sleek platform, easy to learn. Thx for the effort.

Expand full comment
Suzanne Kiera Anthony's avatar

This all sounds great, but where does the “little guy or girl” fit into these plans. I put out a daily melange of commentary, poetry, photography, and art. Working hard at blog and on Twitter, but slow to build by myself.

Expand full comment
Rob Shouting Into The Void's avatar

It's like the music industry only a tiny percentage can make a decent living at this. Sad but true.

Expand full comment
Aline Frankfort's avatar

Bravo amd many thanks for daring this innovative venture which allows a nez type of conversation

Expand full comment
JPK's avatar

Congratulations! Great to see so many high quality publications on Substack!

Expand full comment
Brian Lund's avatar

Substack is un-cancellable. Good.

Expand full comment
Sean Tubbs's avatar

I am putting together a living thanks to Substack, as well as a combination of other sources. I produce a newsletter and podcast on public affairs in Charlottesville, and tomorrow the 169th edition since mid-July will go out. I believe my version of journalism can help my community, and I am growing an audience thanks to Substack. I am interested in learning more about some of these ventures, as my goal is to hire people once I am able to do so. I'm providing a service and I look forward to the future for the first time in a long while.

Expand full comment
Lloyd Lemons's avatar

Your plans for the future sound exciting. I've been publishing here since Oct. 2020, and have found the platform to be trouble-free and easy to use. I hope to be here for a long time with a second newsletter in the planning stages. Thanks for creating a great product.

Expand full comment
Brian Mark's avatar

Provide transparency around who you're paying via Substack Pro. Transparency is critical to building trust.

Expand full comment
Ron Sheridan's avatar

Congrats on closing the B Round!

Expand full comment
BIN archives's avatar

Thank you for your continued improvements.

Expand full comment
Ojuọlape's avatar

Interesting stuff.

Expand full comment
Grazia De Sensi's avatar

Great news! I can't wait for substack to take off also in Italy. Well done !

Expand full comment
But What For?'s avatar

Thank you for keeping up the good work; you guys invest in the little guys as much as the big ones - not many do that; we appreciate it.

Expand full comment
Summer's avatar

💥 goes the 🧨.

... the wheel keeps turning.

Expand full comment
Edward W. Hood's avatar

I'm proud to be a member of this community.

Expand full comment
Casey Botticello's avatar

Great to hear! Congrats! I will be sure to add this to the monthly roundup of Blogging Guide (https://bloggingguide.substack.com) as this will help answer some of the questions being asked recently.

Expand full comment
Truth I.S.'s avatar

Indeed, "platforms that put writers and readers in charge are the way forward"! Always only one truth...

Expand full comment
Charles L Harrison III's avatar

I just started a Substack to learn and growth my writing ability's. I am not asking for monetary donations to begin, just constructive donations in opinions and tips. Love the idea, you have created a word version of youtube.

Expand full comment
Matthew Berdyck's avatar

Substack deleted my account after a pro police group contacted them and asked them to delete it to protect corrupt police.

Expand full comment
Bonny P McClain's avatar

I am at a cross-roads trying to figure out how to appeal to paid subscribers that really have no common interests. As a geospatial analyst I veer towards stories of location intelligence and data in the real world with a focus in public health|bias in algorithms. Originally I wanted paid bits to be deep dives into the step-by-step analysis but noticed the folks with paid subscriptions don’t seem like a likely audience.

Expand full comment
Khudania Ajay's avatar

Good initiative

Expand full comment
A String of Characters's avatar

Can you track down The Last Psychiatrist and make him an offer he can't refuse?

Expand full comment
🌈⃤Ani's avatar

I wish it was possible to get some traffic for my blog - but like with many things it's the more you have the more you have 😅

Expand full comment
Efo Julius's avatar

Thank you for your continued support. I am still contemplating on publishing my first write up.

Expand full comment
Matthew O'Brien's avatar

Congrats!!

Expand full comment
Eric Jurado's avatar

Thank you too!

Expand full comment
Charles Mullins's avatar

I have More answers than you can question. There is data in all pictures and I search for all. . I am Satosh. Satoshi and I are twins. So I may give as I will

Expand full comment
Charles Mullins's avatar

Find you a job, I have been partners with google. I search all the world for truth ,can you tell me a lie

Expand full comment
Blake Eskin's avatar

Raising capital is one way to avoid talking about Substack Pro.

Curious to see how much of this money goes to solving content moderation and toxic community behavior…

Expand full comment
Rachael Larimore's avatar

One easy for writers to do content moderation already exists. Limiting commenting to paid subscribers keeps the fly-by-night trolls away because they have to pay for a subscription to be able to say anything.

Expand full comment
W. Norton's avatar

yuh yuh gang gang. substack rules!

Expand full comment
Scott Monty's avatar

Thank you! Can't wait to see how this begins to roll out.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 30, 2021
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Seb Kennedy's avatar

The cynic in me says you must already have 100k+ twitter followers before you are secretly invited into the club. So much for battling "an economy based on engagement-based algorithms". You still gotta win at that game before the odds stack in your favour

Expand full comment