208 Comments

I have begun working with a start-up online news source, The Colorado Switchblade. We intend to write deep investigative and features pieces. We ran part one of a series of stories Monday about allegations made against a high school teacher for inappropriate touching and language. All of the Title IX investigative docs were leaked to us. We didn't publically identify the 3 accusers or the additional 5 women who corroborated the allegations. This is a small town and the women made no secret of the charges. It's fair to say they outed themselves, but although their identities were not revealed, two parents complained, threatened law suits, and the school investigators said our story had made the women fearful of retribution. All three declined to be interviewed. Because we don't want to face lawsuits, and do not yet have representation, we took down the story, for the moment, but we are continuing to investigate the allegations. The teacher is much beloved by most of his students.

Expand full comment

Would Julian Assange and Wikileaks have been protected under SubStack's umbrella?

Expand full comment

I love the Office Hours discussions. How do I find past editions? Are they searchable or indexed in some way? If I kinda remember a comment in a thread, and want to look it up, how do I find it?

Expand full comment

Thanks for coming to Office Hours this week. I see some new faces! The Substack team is signing off for today.

Special shoutout to Mike and Tim for answering legal questions today.

If you are facing legal uncertainty or pressure because of your writing, we encourage you to learn more about Substack Defender: https://on.substack.com/p/legal-support-for-substack-writers

We'll be back next week for Office Hours as usual. Save it to your calendar: https://lu.ma/office-hours

The week following as we enter October, we'll have our favorite thread: Shoutouts! All that and more at: https://substack.com/events

Signing off,

Katie + Bailey + Rose + Mike + Tim + Jairaj + Lulu + Ben + Ari + James + Lisa

Expand full comment

I have a question for the Substack team that is not a legal issue. It's about using that recording option to just read a post. I have done several drafts already, but have not published. If you record your post, does it automatically go out with the post to email and to our website? I'm trying to time it so the email recipients only get one email that contains both the written post and the recorded oral reading. I believe you thought this was a good idea—to give subscribers another way to access our posts. Im confused about the correct timing of doing this.

Thanks!

Expand full comment

thank for this generous offering!

Expand full comment

Hey thanks for this opportunity. Question: What copyright licenses are necessary to obtain for republication of excerpts from scientific papers/studies with one or more authors listed? I'd like to publish/post various copies of published studies from pubmed and other scientific databases online. I imagine each original publication has their own licensing terms & membership requirements, but to be safe is it necessary to obtain a license from each author listed in each study? Or is a republication license from the original publication generally sufficient?

Expand full comment

I have a hobby of taking already published photos and writing humorous captions to them. For example, President Obama was attending an important international political convocation and he was photographed with a beautiful, blond, svelte young woman who was then ambassador to or from Denmark. (Not sure of this; might have been some other Scandinavian country.) But Michelle was seated to their side observing the obviously good-natured and happy sharing that was going on between the other two. Her face bore an unmistakable angry and troubled expression . The caption:

Just wait til I get you home, Sucka...

My question: Can I use someone else's photos for this purpose? Will I be breaking the law if I do?

Thank you in advance for your answer.

Expand full comment

I wrote a blog for Wordpress several years ago, but when I went to try to upload it to my newsletter, the legal mumbo jumbo scared me off. Does that blog I wrote belong just to me?

Expand full comment

I wondering if there is any legal issue with readership age: if I post MG (middle-grade, ages 9-11 or so) novels on Substack... will that be a problem?

Expand full comment

Actual legal question: if I wrote an article which originally appeared in another publication, am I at risk of running afoul by republishing it on my substack? I never signed away my copyright in any way at the time of publication.

Expand full comment

Thanks for hosting this substack, as always you are super dope! If anyone wants to cross promote/do shout outs, let me know. Happy to grow together.

Expand full comment

How do i get permission to use pics? What is the legal issue using pics from google etc.

Expand full comment

After 3 weeks of publishing a weekly newsletter, Health & Wealth reached over 100 subscribers! 🎉

This was built entirely from scratch - published with my first name only / a new Twitter account @healthwealthgen starting with 0 followers. My thanks to all the H&W early adopters for giving my work a slice of their attention 🙏

I was going to ask a question about photo licenses, but that's already been asked by someone!

So instead: I've been reading some of Substack's growth tactic resources and would love to hear from more fellow writers — what have been some of the highest yield strategies you've used to grow your audience?

Still very new to this, open to suggestions/feedback as well as cross-promotions/collabs with those who write about topics related to health, science, or investing :)

Expand full comment

I can't get in to the meeting

Expand full comment

If we post something and do run into potential legal trouble, what is the protocol for asking for assistance from the legal team if it is appropriate?

Expand full comment

how do i take what i've written off of substack?

Expand full comment

Not a legal question, but you force people to charge at least $30/yr or $5/mo. Others do not have this, making me inclined to use one of those. Any plans to allow us to charge whatever we want since we are not 4?

Expand full comment

1) Do you have any links to anti-SLAPP motions you've filed successfully in California state courts? 2) Have you been able to transfer defamation and other anti-speech cases to federal court? If so, other than diversity jurisdiction, how? 3) given CA's anti-SLAPP law, which venue do you believe is most favorable to the CA writer?

Expand full comment

Not a legal question, but could the substack team take a look at adding an edit function when adding links to the main page? Am I missing something? It seems I can only delete and make new links, not edit them.

Expand full comment

same experience here - i think it's just this thread - not a video

Expand full comment

the link keeps taking me to this page it is circular

Expand full comment

What is the easiest way to transfer content from Blogger to Substack en masse?

Expand full comment

Is this a live event? Where's the link to join...?

Expand full comment

I had a blog that I did not renew and was thus sold off to someone who then posted my articles as if it was his. A few friends from the US told me that I should take action against him. I did nothing of that sort as all I had wanted was for my articles to be read by as many as possible.

As far as I am concerned whatever I write is for public consumption and they may do what they like with it.

My sole aim in writing what I have discovered over the years by teaching dyslexic kids is to educate the public. The more readers who share it or copy it and use it as their own the better.

Expand full comment

Question about parody vs satire. I can create film parodies of Harry Potter that are legally protected, but if I re-use clips from the movies to satirize racism or colonialism or other topics, am I protected?

Expand full comment

Happy Thursday everyone!! In honor of today's topic, a fun movie involving the legal profession is "Legally Blonde" (2001) about Elle Woods (Reese Witherspoon), a college student who enters Harvard Law School in an effort to win back her ex-boyfriend.

Life Lesson: Learn to see the potential in yourself and in others.

Movie Scene: https://moviewise.wordpress.com/2013/08/27/legally-blonde/

If anyone has any favorite movies they would like share, consider writing a "Guest Post" on moviewise 🍿: https://moviewise.substack.com/s/-guest-posts

Expand full comment

Hello to the Substack attorneys and my fellow writers,

IMy question for the attorneys is about using photos. How do I know if they are "royalty free"? If they are NOT affiliated with a stock agency? I noticed that some Substack writers (Michael Moore), for one, uses photos and gives a photo credit, like: Getty Images, Steve Hall, for example. But it's certainly possible he paid a fee for the use of that photo. Unless I'm looking in the wrong places, it is pretty difficult to come up with a decent photo that clearly says it is free for anyone to use. What am I missing? And thanks!

Expand full comment

Thanks to the Substack team for providing this venue. I'd like to hear from the legal team their view of having a paid substack as a sole proprietor or an LLC. I've had an LLC before and it was a lot of paperwork, deadlines, and filings. I'd really prefer not to go down that road again, if possible. Thanks for advice.

Expand full comment

I could use a legal defense because readers say my Substack is killing it! But in all seriousness, people are going to copy/steal/use your work. I already see it in my SEO results, it happens. What can we do?

Expand full comment

Because I question the official narrative about the pandemic and the vaccines and cite official vaccine death count numbers from the CDC's VAERS site (nearly 15,000 deaths to date), I've been censorsed on google owned platforms like youtube and gmail for about 6 months now. Also, to a lesser extent on facebook. In other words, I not allowed to cite official facts put out by the government, nor can I make a comment or post a link to my substack on those platforms. In short, my Constitutional rights to free speech have been taken away. Do I have any legal recourse?

Expand full comment

Great opportunities I never I intended to be a part of. I need to delete this part without losing my connection/subscription to Alex Berenson. Thank you so much. 😔

Expand full comment

I guess a good question is: Are these lawyers going to take cases where, for example, if I had no access to funds, and possibly couldn't pay them back? I would fight the case, but It would be a hard thing to think about the responsibilities of having to pay a lawyer when a good lawyer is hard to find and keep. Also fighting the case as well, and thinking about all the possibilities of losing a case too.

Expand full comment

Do you have any recommendations or guidelines around disclaimers for financial advice? I include one in my footnotes, but I’d really appreciate any feedback about handling this. (For context, I write an investing newsletter that analyzes companies.)

Expand full comment

Not a legal question: I would like to publish a webinar series on S/S and charge for it. Will that fly in your terms of service?

Expand full comment

How does the legalities work outside the United States?

Expand full comment

readers say my substack is illegal, it instantly improved their lives. join the philosophical community.

Expand full comment

OK, so, if I'm writing an article, and I quote a tweet in it, and that tweet contains an image, AND it's the first image in the article, it will automatically set that image as the splash image for the article itself.

Let's say the image is not public domain: should I be worried about this?

Expand full comment

Greetings fellow Stackers, My query is not on legal matters but on advertising analytics. Can one attain a Google analytics pixel ID through one's site on Substack? What about Google tag manager. Thanks

Expand full comment

This isn’t a question about legal, but I was just wondering how ios 15 is expected to affect open rates on Substack?

Expand full comment

Hi there Substack writers, a couple of weeks ago I asked the community about Reddit - some had earlier opined that it was a good place for finding one's readership. I jumped into the site and was immediately shut down, just for saying "hello" to the Writing subreddit. I promised to follow up with my subsequent experience.

Learnings:

1) one of you pointed me in the direction of a detailed onboarding document, written by Reddit, about how to behave in their world; this was super helpful and I have been guided by it ever since

2) Reddit is one odd place on the internet, a mix of kind / helpful souls, confused souls, and trolls; navigating through these is an art-form, to say the least; I started with a handful of subreddits, just looking and commenting helpful words here and there; eventually I landed on a small set of subreddits that make sense for my topics of interest

3) next came the karma effort; karma is their virtual currency that allows you to contribute content without being shutdown; very different from Twitter; following the example of Substack's First1000 author, I dedicated time every day for a couple of weeks, gently adding helpful advice to redditors asking various questions; soon I reached the magic 100 karma points

4) and so, this week, I published the September edition of The Strategy Toolkit (on strategy & biology); via Substack, I was able to post to the strategy subreddit; the next day, I followed up with a post to the biology subreddit

Overall, a time intensive effort but successful in terms of outbound. I will let you know if I gain any subscribers as a result.

I can't join live later today, unfortunately.

George

Expand full comment

Are there any legal complications entailed if doing consulting relating to your Substack? For example, if someone wanted to hire me to consult on a problem, is there a process that I need to follow with Substack to stay right with the law? I'm assuming that thinks like NDA's with the customer would be worked out between them, and that normal ethical "disclose conflicts of interest" apply. What I'm asking is what does consulting affect about my relationship with Substack, or with my copyright.

Expand full comment

Hi Substack Team!

I use Genius Links for Amazon affiliate links in my newsletter. Somewhere I read that Substack automatically deletes the affiliate ID. I want tot check whether this works for Genius Links as well?

Does anyone else use Amazon affiliate links?

Thanks!

Rishi

Expand full comment

I write TV show reviews, and I use screenshots to illustrate my points. I believe using screen shots from the TV shows falls under Fair Use, but is there any specific labeling I need to do? Right now I have an email footer that says 'all images are property of their respective owners', but do I need to get more specific?

Expand full comment

Does Stripe on S/S operate like Medium, where you need to form an entity, along with a physical address in order to charge money?

Expand full comment

This topic couldn't have come at a better time! Here's my question:

I'm acquainted with a professional photographer who doesn't want her photos copied and used by random people. She has given me permission to use certain photos of hers, but with attribution. My concern is that people reading my blog can click to save the photo and use it anyway, despite the copyright. Therefore, I created a watermark on the photo to make it less useable to others.

As an example, the fourth photo down on my latest post shows this watermark:

https://createsoulspace.substack.com/p/psychological-physical-violence

Is this adequate protection to help deter people who may potentially steal the photo? Again, the photographer has only required that mention the photo is hers, yet I want to go a step beyond in an effort to protect her art and livelihood. Thank you!

Expand full comment

I see that writers must apply to the Substack Defender program, which I'm guessing means limited resources and triage. Is there any sort of insurance available through Substack it elsewhere, particularly in the case of nuisance suits? My student newspaper was occasionally threatened with legal action back in the day, but we either ignored it or wrote a retraction, depending. This was many years ago. Are there any new concerns we need to be aware of? Any specific instances of Substackers being sued or harassed?

Expand full comment

This is a sound plan.

Expand full comment

Hi everyone! Sharing some insight on how I grew my subscribers this week - some free ways and some paid.

www.oddjobsnews.com/welcome

I started Odd Jobs Newsletter in July and was able to grow it to over 1,000 subscribers by putting in 2-3 hours of work a week.

Here's what worked really well.

1. Giveaways

I did 3 giveaways and was able to get a huge increase of subscribers. I gave away t-shirts and books (so it didn't cost me very much) and incentivized people to share the newsletter as a way of gaining extra entires to the giveaway.

2. Google Ads

I had never tried Google ads before but this worked so well. I had a budget of $10 a day and researched keywords that my audience would be searching for that applied to the newsletter. I was able to get over 300 subscribers in a week doing this with a low ad budget.

3. Shareable Content

Every week, I make sure my newsletters are valuable, interesting, and unique so readers feel inclined to share with their friends. Plus, it's free so people want to pass along the good info. with the people they adore.v

Expand full comment