107 Comments

Share your advice with us here!: https://substack.com/@substackwriters/note/c-17348630

Expand full comment

The other great advice was to customize the welcome email asking subscribers to tell me why they subscribed. I've developed some meaningful relationships from that alone!

Expand full comment

Perhaps the only piece of advice that really matters in the end: Substack is a long game--think in terms of years, not months, i.e., keep going!

The best part about staying with your Substack and not giving up is that the more you write the better a writer you become, so there's absolutely no downside. What we're doing here as writers is old-school learning on the job the way the masters did before graduate programs took over and (arguably) made people think writing had to look and sound a certain way. We're right where we're supposed to be.

Expand full comment

The best piece of substack advice? Well, a dear friend told me to start a substack, and that was solid advice.

Expand full comment

To be consistent, and to support others’ work and build a community of writers alongside building your Substack. This has changed the way I think and work.

Expand full comment

Best advice: when you get feedback or a comment, ask a question back to keep the engagement going!

Expand full comment

Write weekly!

Expand full comment

The best advice I got was to stay consistent and not too much all over the place. So that your readers can expect what you’ll be posting. And also appreciating every single subscriber without focusing too much on your numbers. Every single subscriber shared their email information with you, or they gifted you some of their daily time to leave a comment. In today’s fast-paced world genuine interaction, without any hurry, seems more rare.

Expand full comment

Best advice: Write truly, honestly and authentically, and also: Promote your work! Don’t buy into the myth that it’s ‘bad’ to self-promote. That seems to be a new trend. Don’t be spammy; don’t just not engage and add your links to everything. It’s not a binary. Engage and add something meaningful to someone’s post and also promote your work if it’s appropriate, meaning if you wrote something connected to the topic you’re commenting on. No one else will do this work for you. Most of us will never have 10,000 subscribers. We build slowly. We advocate for ourselves.

Michael Mohr

‘Sincere American Writing’

https://michaelmohr.substack.com/

Expand full comment

Recently a reader reminded me that the lack of distance between writers and readers does not make the readers Managing Editors. It's a good piece of advice, as following reader preferences too closely could lead the author astray.

Obviously it's important to listen to feedback and engage, but dramatically altering a newsletter because of the loudest fans may be a major mistake.

Expand full comment

Consistency is key.

Expand full comment

To keep expanding yourself thru your writing

Expand full comment

According to Substack, the best advice is to be famous and an established successful writer with a massive following.

Only then will you be featured and...well, grow your audience more!

Expand full comment

https://substack.com/@writersatwork has really great tips for the fundamentals of the substack platform!

Expand full comment

No advice received yet via Notes in particular, but I’ve gotten a couple restacks that way, which is nice.

Expand full comment

Advice received and repeated many times - Keep writing, and post regularly.

Expand full comment